Two Fridays ago, Scott Ladner’s son Henry was at the last walkthrough practice for Weddington Middle’s first football game when an administrator pointed to him and several other players.
They had been exposed to a student who tested positive for COVID-19, contact tracing had found. They were told to leave practice immediately and remain home for 14 days.
- Henry, who was wearing a mask at the moment, instantly became one of more than 7,000 kids the Union County Schools quarantine list.
Scott and his wife, Darcey, spent the next week trying to get him back into school. They sent in negative COVID test results. They sent a positive long-term antibody test result. They said that he’d been wearing a mask constantly, despite the fact that Union remains one of the only school systems in the state where masks are optional.
Still Henry remained home, as did his two younger siblings. Until Monday.
Driving the news: The week broke with news that Ladner had been hoping for: Union County’s school board voted 8-1 to end contact tracing and mandatory quarantines.
- All students who aren’t COVID-19 positive and don’t have symptoms can return to school immediately.
- The decision goes against Union County’s health department’s advice, and the advice of state and federal officials.
Many parents were furious yesterday.“They took the wrong lesson away from the high quarantine numbers,” parent Sarah Miller said in an interview with The Charlotte Observer.
- But Scott Ladner calls it sensible. He says all of his three kids wear masks in schools, are healthy, and want to go back as soon as they can.
Why it matters: Union County, which borders Mecklenburg and has the sixth-largest school system in North Carolina, continues to write its own script on COVID-19. And it’s created an interesting geographic case study in protocols with its neighbor, Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools.
- Union is one of only three school systems out of 115 statewide to leave masks optional, while CMS was one of the first to make them mandatory this summer.
By the numbers: Early results show the masks working. In the third full week of school (Sept. 6-10) Union County had 479 students test positive out of a total student population of about 40,000.
- That same week, CMS had 372 students test positive out of a total student population of about 143,000.
Flashback: Last week, Union County seemed on the cusp of joining the rest of the state in requiring masks, but voted 5-4 to keep them optional. The meeting was tense.
- WFAE’s Ann Doss Helms captured this very 2021 school board moment, writing that the group in favor of mandatory masks sang “Lean on Me” and the national anthem, while those opposed wore red, white and blue clothing and circled the parking lot with Trump 2020 and Don’t Tread on Me flags.
Scott Ladner tells me that he doesn’t think mask mandates or mandatory quarantines or contact tracing are bad policies on their own. But he says it became pretty clear after three weeks that having masks optional while requiring 14-day quarantines created a “mathematical certainty that the school and sports will not survive this fall.”
- “It’s sort of this toxic combination of optional masks and mandatory 14-day quarantine. That was the witch’s brew.”
The big picture: The Charlotte region is a Petri dish for most of America’s modern conflicts — with a more progressive urban core neighboring a conservative but growing and changing county like Union, which borders South Carolina and all of its policies.
- “If you go from Charlotte to Union County to South Carolina, you get three different realities,” Scott Ladner said. “I’m not here to say one is better, but we all know that these aren’t really health decisions being made; these are political decisions being made.
- “Every parent wants kids in schools. That goal goes across the three lines. But the way they get to that goal couldn’t be more different.”